Showing posts with label May God Have Mercy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label May God Have Mercy. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 14, 2018

Nevermore: Sailing Alone, Coldest Winter, Roger Coleman, London Rain



Reported by Ambrea

Nevermore started off with a pertinent poem by Billy Collins:
“The name of the author is the first to go
Followed obediently by the title, the plot,
The heartbreaking conclusion, the entire novel
Which suddenly becomes one you have never read, never even heard of,

As if, one by one, the memories you used to harbor
Decided to retire to the southern hemisphere of the brain,
To a little fishing village where there are no phones.”



Our reader checked out Sailing Alone Around the Room, telling her fellow Nevermore members that she thought it was pertinent and she “thought about us [Nevermore].”  She raved about Collins’ collected poems and highly recommended them, saying they were fun and interesting and astonishingly relatable.


Next, Nevermore shared The Coldest Winter:  America and the Korean War by David Halberstam, which delves deep into the Korean War and takes a long, hard look at the political decisions—and miscalculations—that prolonged the conflict.  Our reader noted that Halberstams’ book was incredibly heavy, literally and figuratively.  A monumental book in both its size and scope, The Coldest Winter was an interesting and comprehensive volume on the Korean conflict.  Although our reader was only partially finished with the book, she said it was filled with “a lot of people screwing up and screwing people over.”  Her review of Halberstams’ book lead to a great discussion of the start and the events that defined the Korean War.


Continuing in the vein of nonfiction, Nevermore looked at May God Have Mercy:  A True Story of Crime and Punishment by John C. Tucker.  In 1982, in Buchanan County, Virginia, a young coal miner named Roger Coleman was sentenced to death for the murder of his sister-in-law.  Despite the best efforts of Kitty Behan, a brilliant young lawyer who devoted two years of her life to gathering evidence in Coleman’s defense, Coleman was sentenced to death ten years later—and the shocking truth of the crime revealed.  Our reader said May God Have Mercy was a fascinating book with local ties.  It was both riveting and informative, offering a glimpse into the judicial process and how the handling of evidence has changed over the years.


Next, Nevermore shared London Rain, a Josephine Tey mystery by Nicola Upson.  Josephine Tey is an intrepid writer and an amateur sleuth, who often manages to step into mysteries that are nearly as dramatic as the plays she writes.  This time, Josephine is wrapped up in the murder of Anthony Beresford, Britain’s most venerable newsman, as the coronation of King George looms on the horizon—and war bubbles just beneath the surface of Europe.  Our reader said she didn’t care much for Upson’s novel.  Although she read the entire book, she admitted she only did so with the vain hope it would get better.  Overall, London Rain, while captivating for its portrait of pre-World War II London, was disappointing. (Note: for the uninitiated, the real Josephine Tey was a well-known Golden Age mystery author, best known for A Daughter of Time.)


Last, Nevermore took a look at Evicted:  Poverty and Profit in the American City by Matthew Desmond.   Winner of the 2017 Pulitzer Prize for General Non-Fiction, Evicted is a heart-wrenching expose on the state of poverty in the United States.  For much of the book, Desmond follows the path of eight families in Milwaukee as they struggle to keep a roof over their heads and fight to stay afloat amidst financial devastation.  Our reader said Evicted was a moving depiction of poverty and loss, sadness and tragedy interspersed with real scenes of hope within the home.  “It is overwhelming…[to see] the way their resources were so limited, so stretched,” she said.  She found it to be enlightening, an eye-opening experience, and she highly recommended it to her fellow Nevermore members.

Wednesday, March 7, 2018

Nevermore: Flora, Water Will Come, Lady in Shadows, Borrower, Roger Coleman, Winter Ghosts






Reported by Kristin

Nevermore began the week with what was termed a “lovely book,” Flora by Gail Godwin.  Flora is a young woman charged with caring for Helen, a ten year old whose mother is dead and whose father is working at the secret war facility in Oak Ridge, Tennessee.  Decades later, grown up Helen tells her story about the summer they spent in isolation on a mountaintop, regretting her pre-teen scheming against the naive Flora.   Connecting with the novel on a local level, our reader said that it was funny, poignant, and beautifully written.

Next up was The Water Will Come: Rising Seas, Sinking Cities, and the Remaking of the Civilized World by Jeff Goodell.  A cautionary tale of global warming, this work of non-fiction talks about how coastal cities such as Manhattan, Miami, Venice, Rotterdam and many more are at risk of losing land to rising sea levels.  Our reader said that she wasn’t sure if Goodell would be convincing to someone who might argue with climate change science, but with her he was preaching to the choir.


Returning to fiction, the next reader enjoyed a walk on the creepy side with A Lady in Shadows by Lene Kaaberbøl.  Nineteenth century forensic scientist student Madeleine Karno works amidst chaos and gore.  Finding out who has killed a prostitute becomes her mission, and her unique position as a woman may give her some advantage.  Our reader said that the story had a very involved plot, but was nicely executed.


The Borrower by Rebecca Makkai brought a children’s librarian’s story to the table, a story in which Lucy Hull finds herself assisting 10-year-old Ian Drake when he decides to run away from home.  When Lucy finds Ian in the library after hours, she tells herself that she will just drive him home, but ends up on a road trip across the country as he reveals more about his home life.  Our reader found it a very unnerving book, feeling that Lucy had stepped into a most difficult ethical situation once she made the first choice to help Ian.


A regional crime story encouraged much discussion with May God Have Mercy: A True Story of Crime and Punishment by John C. Tucker.  In Grundy, Virginia, Roger Coleman was convicted of murdering his sister-in-law.  Ten years later in 1992, Coleman was executed for the crime, although much doubt still surrounded the verdict.  Years after Coleman’s death, DNA evidence indicated that he was indeed guilty, but many people remain unsure of what to believe.  Our readers’ views were mixed, much like the community of Grundy at large.


Lastly, another reader enjoyed The Winter Ghosts by Kate Mosse, a post-World War I tale as Freddie Watson travels through a blizzard in the French Pyrenees.  After a car crash, Freddie ends up staying in a small village inn where he meets the beautiful young woman Fabrissa.  Freddie must search out answers as he confronts his own personal losses and the ghosts of a mystery hidden for centuries.  Our reader very much enjoyed the Gothic flavor of the novel.

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Nevermore: Ellsburg, Halbertham, Wolff, Pullman, Vonnegut





Reported by Jeanne
Nevermore opened with Doomsday Machine by Daniel Ellsberg.  Ellsberg, who copied and released the Pentagon Papers, was also involved with studying the “fail-safe” system with was supposed to prevent the launch of nuclear weapons without proper authorization.  He was appalled by what he found.  Our reader found the book hard to read because of all the acronyms; a veritable “alphabet soup,” but thought it was also timely.


The Coldest Winter by David Halberstam is another timely book.  Although it was written about the Korean War, our reader said it was like reading today’s papers. Many of the personality types remain the same as does the aims of the North Korean leadership.  The book was described as well researched, with much information about  the various generals involved.  There was so much detail about these men, according to our reader, that the only mystery left was “boxers or briefs.”


Our next reader brought up Fire and Fury by Michael Wolff which describes the ferocious infighting between White House factions of the Trump administration.  Many things in the book had already appeared in the media, but Wolff provides much more detail.  The book ends in October, 2017.  While the book was entertaining, questions about fact checking did arise.



A regional true crime book, May God Have Mercy by John C. Tucker, describes the case against Roger Keith Coleman who was convicted of murdering his sister-in-law in Buchanan County, Virginia.  Coleman was sentenced to death and executed, but maintained his innocence.  His supporters did not give up after his death, but continued to work to try to clear his name.  The book convinced some Nevermore readers that there had been a miscarriage of justice.  (Note:  this book came out in 1997, five years after Coleman’s execution, but before the results of a 2006 DNA test were known.)



Fiction finally came to the fore with Phillip Pullman’s Book of Dust.  The first of a new trilogy, the book is set in the same world as The Golden Compass but it’s described as neither prequel nor sequel, though parts are set before and after the events in His Dark Materials.  Lyra, heroine of the first books, shows up as a baby in Book of Dust.  Eleven year old Malcolm is enchanted by the infant and will try to protect her.  Our reviewer highly recommends the three books of His Dark Materials and thought the new book was a worthy addition.  


Complete Stories by Kurt Vonnegut consists of the author’s shorter work, both published and unpublished at the time of his death.  Our reader had read and enjoyed Vonnegut’s work before and praised this collection.  He compared the stories to fables, and added, “You think you know where the story is going, and then Vonnegut surprises you.”