Nevermore: Hand to Mouth, We Learned Nothing, Great and Holy War, Book Woman of Troublesome Creek, Poisonwood Bible

Reported by Lauren

                This week we kicked off our discussion with Hand to Mouth: Living in Bootstrap America by Linda Tirado. Hand to Mouth has earned rave reviews from critics, and is even assigned in college sociology and anthropology classes. The author describes her experiences living poor in America, including her difficulty making ends meet, paying for childcare and her smoking habit, and her family’s fight to get her husband’s military benefits. Our reviewer began by saying she hated everything about this book: the author had a defeatist attitude, she blamed everyone and everything else for her problems but refused to take responsibility for her actions, and our reader was struggling to get through it. As we discussed the issues that impoverished Americans face on a daily basis however, she eventually said, “You know, maybe this book is affecting me more than I thought.” Another reader chimed in saying, “It definitely stayed with me after I read it—I have been attempting to not be so judgmental when I meet new people now.” While this book wasn’t a favorite, it definitely sparked a thought-provoking discussion.

                Our next member shared her thoughts on We Learned Nothing by Tim Kreider. Kreider is a well-known cartoonist who has ventured into the land of short stories. This reader praised his sense of humor, but found the stories insightful and poignant as well. Sometimes we really don’t learn from the mistakes of our past or others’. She also shared When Death Becomes Life: Notes from a Transplant Surgeon by Joshua D. Dedrich. She mentioned that this book was pretty in-depth and a little long on history, but she enjoyed learning about the history of organ transplants, and that once the drug that inhibits organ rejections was discovered, the transplant game changed forever.

                Another book clubber offered a different perspective on the first world war by sharing Philip Jenkin’s The Great and Holy War: How World War I Became a Religious Crusade. This member never realized just how much influence the Protestant and Catholic Churches had on the war. The media was just becoming mainstream, and various religions capitalized on this unprecedented method of sharing information by creating propaganda that advanced their belief systems. According to Jenkins, the Catholic Church claimed Jesus was actually Aryan rather than Jewish, and that Jewish people were responsible for His death. Jenkins believes that this religious zeal set the stage for WWII and the rise of Anti-Semitism and Nazism. Our reader found the book fascinating, describing it as scholarly and well-researched, with an extensive bibliography. She recommended everyone read it to learn more about this time period. 

                Next we discussed Kim Michele Richardson’s latest novel The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek. Set in 1930s Appalachia, it tells the story of one of the fearless and determined Kentucky Pack Horse Librarians, Cussy Mary Carter, who also happens to be one of the Kentucky Blue People. This fascinating novel paints a vivid picture of the hardships of this era, and praises the women who spared no efforts to spread literacy and learning throughout the Appalachian region. Cussy’s personal life is also portrayed—as a “blue” person engaged to a “white” person, her impending marriage is constantly threatened by the racism of her peers. Our reader shared that she was amazed at the danger Cussy puts herself in, not just with her job but also with her relationship. Later on, Cussy is chosen as a subject of a medical study that tries to change her skin color, but even though she dreams of being white, she is not happy with the results of the drug trial. Our reviewer loved this novel, and several of our members were excited to read it as well.

                We closed our meeting with a discussion of the contemporary classic The Poisonwood Bible by Barbara Kingsolver. Almost all of our Nevermore members had read this novel at some point, and all sang its praises calling it “life-changing” and “vital.” Written by one of Appalachia’s own daughters, it tells the story of Baptist minister Nathan Price, his wife, and their four daughters and their mission trip to the Belgian Congo in 1959. The Price family endures trials and tribulations, both physical and spiritual, and are forever changed by their experience in the African jungle. Our reader shared several passages with us, lauding Kingsolver’s ability to bring Africa to life through her writing style and word choice. We all agreed that Kingsolver is a fantastic writer, and everyone should read at least one of her novels.

Beyond Left Behind: Luke's Story

Luke’s Story: By Faith Alone by Tim LaHaye and Jerry Jenkins (F LAH Main & Avoca; SSB F LAH Main)
Reviewed by Susan

If you like stories in Bible School, then this book is for you. Third of the “Jesus Chronicles,” it re-constructs Luke’s life from childhood up to his old age. Tim LaHaye & Jerry Jenkins authored the wildly popular “Left Behind” series. They are trying to hit another one out of the ballpark with mixed results. So far, they’ve done Mark’s Story (super-good) and John’s Story (not their best). Luke’s Story makes you nod your head, thinking, “Yeah. It could have been this way.”

Curious. Compassionate. Luke helps another slave in a serious accident, saving his life. This draws the attention of their kindly owner, Theophilius. I had to smile when Theophilius realizes Luke has potential and asks him what field he likes best, and Luke replies, “The bean field.” Working with the family’s physician, Luke is groomed until a plague hits. So many slaves die, including the physician and Luke’s parents. Luke is given more and more tasks, with the plan of eventually sending him to a university to study medicine.

It is there that he meets Saul (Paul), another first year student. Saul, being Saul, is hard to get along with. Saul whips up a marathon race and sweet-talks other first year students to join. Several do, but only Luke & Saul finish, walking across the line together. Foreshadowing.

They become friends. Sort of. Saul admits that when they are older, with his Jewish and Pharisee connections, they will not be able to continue as friends. Luke, of course, feels used, but they kind of work it out.

Fast forward. Luke goes on to become a physician. He hears tales about a murdered Judean carpenter who preached a philosophy heretical to Judaism. Saul went on to root out these heretics until he is converted and becomes a faithful believer. They eventually meet and Saul converts Luke, who diligently studies these new teachings. He has dialogues with Paul and an elderly Mary. Visiting Paul in a Roman prison, Paul predicts that Luke will write the Acts of the Apostles.

LaHaye weaves a pretty good story. He fills it in with things that could have happened, making Luke and Saul multi-dimensional. Where it bogs down is that there is a lot of reproduction of Luke’s Gospel. Also, it’s unlikely that Saul would have been schooled anywhere other than in Judea under a Pharisee rabbi.

So, enjoy it but remember to give it plenty of literary license.