Showing posts with label Giver of Stars. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Giver of Stars. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Nevermore: Moyes, Kline, Theroux, Patton, Robson, Pierce

 Reported by Garry


Our first book reviewed this week was the best-selling The Giver of Stars by Jojo Moyes.  This historical novel is set in the Appalachian region of Kentucky and follows Alice Wright, an English woman who hopes to escape her stifling life.  Things don’t work out quite the way she envisions, and she finds herself stuck in a small town with an over-bearing father-in-law.  When Eleanor Roosevelt creates a traveling library program, Alice leaps at the opportunity, and adventure begins.   This historic fiction novel covers similar themes to The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek, and is soon to be made into a major motion picture.  Our reader highly recommends this book and found it touching, inspiring and very well written. 

 


Next up was The Exiles by Christina Baker Kline, which our reader borrowed digitally through TN Reads.  This historic novel centers on the lives of two young English women who have been sentenced to exile to Van Diemen’s Land – what is now known as Australia.  A third main character is a young Aboriginal girl, Mathinna, the orphaned daughter of an Aboriginal chief, who is adopted by the governor of Van Diemen’s Land, and is treated as a curiosity rather than a human being.  Our reader took particular note of the details of travel on the ship, the prison system in Australia at the time, and how awful both were.  She highly recommends this very interesting book.

 

 

Our next reader took a long and winding journey with through South America with Paul Theroux and his The Old Patagonian Express, which she borrowed from TN Reads.  First published in 1979, this written account retells Theroux’s journey from his home in Massachusetts, by train to Texas, then through Mexico into Guatemala and El Salvador.  Journeying further south by both plane and train Theroux makes his way to the small town of Esquel in Argentinian Patagonia.  Along the way Theroux meets and describes the locals and other travelers, sometimes unflatteringly.  Our reader liked Theroux’s somewhat curmudgeonly writing style and his insight into the people he meets along the way. 

 

Our next book was set on the other southern peninsula – South Africa.  Cry the Beloved Country by Alan Patton was published in 1948 and has become a classic novel.  Our reader initially read this book in high school and recently decided to revisit it.  The story centers on a Zulu pastor, Steven Kumalo and his son, Absalom.  Steven lives out in the country, and is called to Johannesburg to see his ailing sister.  The trip requires him to take 5 trains over 2 days to get to the city.  As well as trying to locate his sister, Steven tries to locate his son, Absalom, who has been arrested for the murder of a white man who was fighting for racial justice.  This novel was written before the system of apartheid was implemented in South Africa, and is a protest against the social structures that lead to the separation of the country along color lines.  Unflinching in its examination of the detrimental effects of systemic racism, our reader found that this novel is as relevant today as it was when she initially read it. 


 

 

Our Darkest Night by Jennifer Robson was the next novel reviewed.  This historical novel is placed in Italy during World War II, and tells the story of Antonina Mazin, a young Jewish girl who lives in Venice.   Antonina wants to become a doctor like her father, but faced with the growing Nazi occupation of Italy, she must leave Venice and hide in the countryside, where she poses as the new bride to Nico Gerardi, a young Italian farmer who had been studying to become a priest before circumstances required him to take over the family farm.  Nico and Antonina must convince the neighbors and local Nazis that they are indeed a young married couple in order to protect their lives.   Our reader really liked this book, and was especially appreciative of the author’s ability to so beautifully picture the village, and noted that while the characters are fictional, the setting and incidents recalled are pulled from reality.  

 

 

Also set in World War II, but this time in England, Dear Mrs. Bird by AJ Pierce was the next book reviewed.  In this historic novel, Emmiline Lake, wants would like to be a war correspondent.  When she lands a position at the London Evening Chronicle, she thinks she is on the road to achieving her dream.  When she arrives, however, she finds her position is that of a typist to the legendary and fierce Mrs. Bird, who rules the advice column with an iron fist.  Our reader loved this sweetly written quick read, and noted how it really does describe what it is like to be in a blitz in England. 

 

Also mentioned:

Take It Back by Kia Abdoulah

Raft of Stars by Andrew Graff

Machinehood by S.B. Divya

The Angry Wife by Pearl S. Buck

The Talented Mr. Ripley by Patricia Highsmith

Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents by Isabel Wilkerson

Stamped from the Beginning by Ibram X Kendi

Hound of the Baskervilles by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

White Teacher by Vivian Paley

Across the Top of the World by David Fisher 

The Three Mothers by Anna Malaika Tubbs

Those Who Are Saved by Alexis Landau

When Twilight Breaks by Sarah Sundin

Friday, December 6, 2019

The Giver of Stars by Jojo Moyes




Reviewed by Laura


          This book is told through the eyes of Alice Wright, a young English woman who impulsively marries a handsome, rich American named Bennett Van Cleve. She is more than ready to be through with the tedium of English society and imagines a beautiful new life when she follows Bennett to his hometown in Kentucky. Only Baileyville, Kentucky  is a small coal mining town with not a city in sight, and from the first night in her new home, nothing is as she dreamed. Instead of a romantic existence with a dashing husband, she is forced to live in the house of her father-in-law, a selfish owner of the local mine who puts profit above all else. Having the majority of the town’s livelihood, and in fact, their very lives in his hands, he feels he can dictate what is and isn’t acceptable. This includes those in his own household as well as the people of Baileyville. Alice is appalled that her husband lives under his father’s thumb and that the romance she envisioned doesn’t exist.

When a call is made for riders for Eleanor Roosevelt’s new traveling library, Alice is happy to oblige. She can’t stand the thought of spending the rest of her days in the stifling, loveless environment of the Van Cleve household. Being able to move freely in the fresh air of the beautiful Kentucky mountains sounds like heaven. It turns out that it is and it isn’t. The work is hard and dangerous, yet the scenery is breathtaking, and Alice makes true friends among the other members of the packhorse librarians while being taken under the wing of their leader, Margery O’Hare. Ms. O’Hare is a true character in every sense of the word (In fact, she reminds me of my paternal grandmother!). She has never allowed anyone, men included, to tell her what to do. This is virtually unheard of during the depression era in a small Appalachian mountain town. Refusing to follow the mainstream, she still works for the good of the town and is the first to take Alice into her home when life goes awry. As they say, no good deed goes unpunished, and due to a series of events, the packhorse librarians find themselves at odds with the townspeople.

This is a wonderful book filled with suspense, romance, and the unique and incredible power of books. There have been rumors of plagiarism from Kim Michele Richardson’s The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek; but having read both, I found no real evidence of it. Certainly, there are a few similarities, as they are both about the wonderfully brave librarians of Eastern Kentucky, but the stories focus on decidedly differing elements of their legacy. I enjoyed both of these books tremendously. Being from Southeastern Kentucky, I love reading anything set in those beautiful mountains, but for me, The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek captured the essence of the mountains and its people in a truer and much more enthralling manner. My advice is to read and enjoy them both, and if you get a chance, let me know which one you preferred!

(Special side note—this book is in development as a major motion picture.)