Friday, November 20, 2026

Seasoned in Appalachia: Delicious Recipes from the Mountains & Hollers by Jimmy Proffitt

 



Reviewed by Jeanne

When I see a cookbook from Appalachia, I vacillate between anticipation and suspicion.  Just who is this author? What are the credentials? And are we talking traditional or modernized or fancied up recipes?

Proffitt was born and raised in the Shenandoah Valley but now resides in East Tennessee, I gather around Pigeon Forge.  He’s described as a “self-taught chef” who started out fixing supper for his family when he was in his teens.   I thought that sounded pretty promising, so I decided to take a look.

I always go to the cornbread recipe first.  I have definite opinions on corn bread, and I have judged many a cookbook on that very item.  Of course, most of us are convinced that the way food was prepared growing up is the gold standard and in my case that meant no sugar in the cornbread.  I can still recall the first time I took a bite of cornbread with sugar.  I hope I had manners enough not to just spit it out.  Anyway, a friend once told me, “If God had intended for there to be sugar in corn bread, He’d have called it cake.” I concur.

Cornbread is also one of the very very very few things I make.

It turns out that he has several corn bread recipes. Brown Butter Cornbread seems to be the basic one and I have to admit I was impressed.  He calls for stone ground cornmeal, an egg, and buttermilk.  He does call for a teaspoon of sugar to help brown the bread but I may forgive him that. And he wasn’t kidding about the butter part: you put a whole stick of butter in the (of course) cast-iron skillet and let it melt while you preheat the pan.

Bloody Butcher Cornbread took me aback for a minute, before reading that it refers to a type of heirloom red corn. Bloody Butcher cornmeal is available from some working gristmills and you can buy online. Otherwise, the recipe was pretty similar to the one I use and I am definitely interested in that cornmeal.

I found myself warming to this cookbook.

And then I found a recipe I might actually try to make: Green Tomato Onion Cornbread. 

Just let that sink in for a moment.

You put bacon grease in the bottom of a cast-iron skillet and then layer it with slices of green tomatoes and onions, let them cook a bit and then pour the cornbread batter over the top.

I didn’t need to read further.  For me, this one is a winner.

I did glance through it a little more and I definitely liked what I saw:  Pone Bread, which was a family favorite growing up; Leather Britches; Pan Gravy, which looked to be like Pepper Gravy (but no Sawmill Gravy); and Snow Cream.  There are a few I didn’t recognize (Belsnickel Cookies) but many were variations on staples like Apple Butter, Drop Biscuits, Bread and Butter Pickles, Deviled Eggs, etc.  He offers some helpful hints (his suggestion for the best way to shell eggs sounded interesting) and some story context for the recipes that bring a warmth to the book.  It’s well illustrated and the photos look as if they are real food, i.e. not perfectly photoshopped.

There is also a very good index.

As is well known, I do not cook.  To have me actually consider making something from a cookbook is the highest recommendation I can give.

Wonder if I can still find green tomatoes this late in the year?

No comments:

Post a Comment